Showing posts with label Charles Murray. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charles Murray. Show all posts

Monday, October 12, 2026

A Ground Breaking Analysis of LBJ's War on Poverty: Charles Murray's Losing Ground

There are two ways people fight facts they don't like. Either they say, "Don't read this," or they deny the facts that it presents. It would seem that this has been the territory Charles Murray has chosen to stake out for the entirety of his writing career, choosing controversial themes and speaking truth to power, as in Facts vs. Liberal Ideology. 

When it comes to Washington, well-meaning politicians routinely attempt to address serious problems via programs that are massively expensive. When their theories result in unintended consequences--and there are always unintended consequences--these same politicians have no interest in acknowledging their failures. Instead, they'll go to the wall to abuse their accusers. In the courtroom of public opinion facts are irrelevant.

I first became aware of the failings of President Johnson's Great Society programs in 1984 through a two issue in-depth analysis of the problems in a four square mile section of South Chicago. The big surprise was not the details unearthed in the article(s). Rather, it was the vocal outcry by black and liberal leaders against the plain facts. Statistics have shown that kids in single parent households become juvenile delinquents at a higher rate than kids in homes with two parents. To many black leaders (cited in the article), expecting a father to stay home and help raise his children was an imposition of "white values." If I remember correctly, 70% of the children in South Chicago were being raised in one-parent homes.

This is not to say that one-parent homes guarantee delinquency. It does, however, point to a problem, one of the unintended consequences of American welfare policies.

The book is Charles Murray’s Losing Ground: American Social Policy, 1950–1980 (1984). It's a data-driven critique of U.S. social welfare policy, particularly the Great Society programs of the 1960s.

Murray's core thesis was that the expansion of welfare and related policies in the mid-1960s and afterward changed the incentives facing the poor in ways that increased dependency, family breakdown, crime, and related social problems—rather than reducing poverty. He contended that policymakers altered “the rules of the game” for the disadvantaged, making short-term behaviors (such as single motherhood, non-work, or crime) less costly while masking their long-term harms. In his words, efforts to provide more for the poor (in this manner) produced more poor people and built a trap instead of an escape.


Murray contrasted pre-1960s trends (when poverty declined steadily amid limited federal welfare) with post-1960s outcomes, when large increases in spending coincided with stalled or reversed progress on key indicators, especially among the black underclass and young people. [EdNote: Thomas Sowell has frequently pointed out that blacks were improving economically every decade of the 20th century until LBJ's Great Society interference.]


Key Evidence and Arguments
Poverty and spending: Official poverty rates fell sharply before the War on Poverty but stalled or worsened in some measures afterward, despite a major expansion of transfer programs (AFDC, food stamps, Medicaid, housing subsidies, etc.).

Labor force and unemployment
: Participation rates and employment among young black men deteriorated relative to earlier decades and relative to whites, even as job-training and other programs expanded.

Family structure
: Rising rates of out-of-wedlock births and single-parent households are linked to welfare rules that often made marriage or work financially less attractive for low-income women than remaining single and relying on benefits. 

Crime and other indicators
: Increases in crime, dropout from the labor force, and related problems are presented as responses to softened consequences (more lenient justice policies, reduced stigma, and subsidized alternatives to work and family).

Incentive analysis
: Using data on benefit levels relative to wages, Murray showed how, in many cases, a single mother could receive more in combined benefits than by taking a low-wage job, reducing the payoff to work and marriage. [EdNote: The same thinking occurred during Covid where workers made more more for not working than working. I spoke with one woman who went back to work because she was bored to death after four months of not working.]


Murray emphasized that the poor respond rationally to the incentives they face. The policy shift, he argued, was rooted in a changed elite consensus that viewed poverty primarily as the fault of “the system” (racism, lack of opportunity) rather than individual behavior or choices, leading to programs that subsidized destructive short-term decisions.


Proposals

Murray advocated rolling back the federal welfare and income-support system for working-age adults (with limited exceptions for the truly needy), returning more responsibility to states and localities, promoting education choice (such as vouchers), and restoring emphasis on personal responsibility, work, and family. He also supported core civil rights protections from the 1964 Act but opposed later race-preferential policies.


Context and Reception

The book was influential among conservatives and helped shape debates that later contributed to 1990s welfare reform. But the critics and liberal analysts generally disputed Murray’s causal claims, data interpretations, and the extent to which welfare rules alone explain the trends, arguing that economic shifts, discrimination, and other factors were more important. 


Murray’s later works--The Bell Curve and Coming Apart--developed related themes around cognitive ability, culture, and class divergence. The reaction from the Left against these books was even more shrill. 


In essence, Losing Ground maintained that well-intentioned anti-poverty policies of the 1960s–1970s inadvertently worsened outcomes for the people they were meant to help by distorting incentives. The lesson for us today: Government leaders--Left and Right--often have good intentions but we need to hold them accountable for the outcomes they produce. 

Monday, February 9, 2015

Thomas Mann's Buddenbrooks: The Decline of a Family

Despite the accessibility of so many resources by means of the Internet, libraries remain an invaluable treasure. For many years it would be my habit to mine certain sections and take out piles of books, gleaning all and reading a couple. One of the sections I mined for a while was the literary criticism section, somewhere in the 800s, if I remember correctly. One of these volume was a book devoted to the three highest peaks in the mountain range of literary figures in the first half of the twentieth century. These three authors were Andre Gide, James Joyce and Thomas Mann.

Joyce I had been familiar with because the fellow across the hall from me in my sophomore year in college had a whole shelf of books about Ulysses, including 20 various versions or the original (if my memory is accurate.) I set about to become familiar with Gide and Mann by reading their works and reading the journals. I wanted to get inside these writer's minds, and t was a rewarding experience.

The novel that put Mann on the map and contributed to his receiving the Nobel Prize for literature was Buddenbrooks, a novel that outlines the decline of a great family over four generations. Here is a description of the book as presented at Goodreads.

Buddenbrooks, first published in Germany in 1901, when Mann was only twenty-six, has become a classic of modern literature.

It is the story of four generations of a wealthy bourgeois family in northern Germany facing the advent of modernity; in an uncertain new world, the family’s bonds and traditions begin to disintegrate. As Mann charts the Buddenbrooks’ decline from prosperity to bankruptcy, from moral and psychic soundness to sickly piety, artistic decadence, and madness, he ushers the reader into a world of stunning vitality, pieced together from births and funerals, weddings and divorces, recipes, gossip, and earthy humor.

In its immensity of scope, richness of detail, and fullness of humanity, Buddenbrooks surpasses all other modern family chronicles. With remarkable fidelity to the original German text, this superb translation emphasizes the magnificent scale of Mann’s achievement in this riveting, tragic novel.

This novel came to mind as I have been reading three other books about the decline not of a family but of a society. Are declines inevitable?

Historically, all great societies rise and fall. We must ask ourselves, why not America? While reading Charles Murray's Coming Apart, which I will talk more about later this week, the statistical facts are nearly indisputable. The strange thing to me is that he does not have a pessimistic view of the future.

A second book I'm reading is called The Great Degeneration: How Institutions Decay and Economies Die, by Niall Ferguson. The cover photo shows an abandoned house with the roof partially caved in. It's the price of complacency. I'm not far enough along to see if he's optimistic at the end, but the case is well made that there's much to be concerned about.

Then there's Joseph Stiglitz's The Price of Inequality: How Today's Divided Society Endangers Our Future. Stiglitz notes that the global economic meltdown that cost us trillions of dollars and from which we have yet to fully recover will repeat itself because the causes have never been addressed. In fact, the one-per-centers were rewarded in the end.

The review for this book includes this: Nobel Prize–winning economist Joseph E. Stiglitz exposes the efforts of well-heeled interests to compound their wealth in ways that have stifled true, dynamic capitalism. Along the way he examines the effect of inequality on our economy, our democracy, and our system of justice.

The decline feels inevitable from where I sit, an attitude that leaves one dangerously complacent about it all. In the end such complacency will destroy us, for it solves nothing. Perhaps that's why so many seem to be on the track of "Eat, drink and be merry for tomorrow we die."

Hmmmm. I'll try for something more upbeat tomorrow.

Popular Posts