Showing posts with label Lynchings in Duluth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lynchings in Duluth. Show all posts

Saturday, June 14, 2014

Michael Fedo Talks About Writing and His Book The Lynchings In Duluth


This year marks the 94th anniversary of that tragedy that ended the lives of Elias Clayton, Elmer Jackson and Isaac McGhie, three young African American men who were falsely accused, taken by a mob from the old Duluth jail on East Superior Street, and lynched at the intersection where the CJM Memorial now stands. Monday June 16 will be a special Day of Remembrance. This is the 11th year since the Clayton Jackson McGhie Memorial’s dedication.

Michael Fedo, cousin of Duluth’s former mayor, is a lifelong writer and the author of 9 books including a short novel. His book The Lynchings In Duluth, has received recognition for its significant contribution to understanding the events of what many consider the Northland’s darkest day. His most recent book Zenith City is getting attention as well for its honesty and his storytelling skills.

EN: What was your career path from youth to career author?

Michael Fedo: I was not an English major, but did minor in it, taking a few writing courses but made only average grades in those classes. I really do blame this on the professors, whose paradigms on good writing, or at least writing for the general population were extremely limited. I wrote a piece about this several years back for the old Loft magazine, but I think it's archived at MinnPost.com under the title "You Were Wrong, Prof. Colllins." Again, I became something of an accidental writer.

EN: What prompted you to take up the story of the lynchings in Duluth?

MF: I never intended to write the lynching story. Back in 1970 or thereabouts, I attempted to write a novel set in post-World War 1 northern Minnesota. I remembered my mother telling me when I was 9 or 10 that some black men had been lynched in Duluth about a mile from where she grew up. I don't recall a context for her telling me this, but I thought I'd include the incident as a chapter in my novel, my main character being a witness to it. To be accurate in my depiction of the lynchings, I sought the book I assumed had been written about it 50 years earlier, but discovered there was no such book. Nor was there much information on the topic in Duluth at all. Collective amnesia was the norm in the city. However, I found court transcripts and newspaper coverage in the State Historical Society archives. After filling a spiral notebook with data over two Saturdays spent in the archives, I abandoned the novel and documented the lynching story instead.

EN: What surprised you most as you wrote this story?

MF: What mostly surprised me about this story was learning that a former employer of mine during my undergraduate days at UMD had been arrested for participating in the crime. Charges were dismissed, but when I called him for an interview he declined and hoped I'd be like most good Duluth citizens, and forget about it. We never communicated again.

EN: What was the hardest part about researching this project?

MF: Researching the subject was difficult only in Duluth, where I was stonewalled, and where files didn't exist. In St. Paul I read papers and court records, and was able to interview folks from Duluth who were knowledgeable because they either knew or were related to people who witnessed the lynchings.

EN: Which do you prefer, fiction or non-fiction and why?

MF: In present day literature I prefer nonfiction because much contemporary so-called mainstream fiction isn't about anything. I can't read a 300 page novel in which we're exposed to what a middle-aged woman (for example) is feeling on a spring day in Albuquerque, or where ever. Back when I was in elementary school and we were made to stand in front of class and give book reports, we had no literary sophistication, so what we told the class was what the story was about--a boy who wanted to become a jockey, and how he loved horses and his struggles in finally winning the blue ribbon at the state fair, or some such. In much contemporary novels, one would be hard pressed to tell anybody what the story was about, or to say something that would elicit interest. This is why the perennially popular novels are genre works--detective, espionage, romance, sci-fi, etc. Genre writers still write stories that are about something beyond thoughts and feelings. Not that I'm a big fan of genre fiction, but stories are inevitable in those formats. T'ain't necessarily so in the mainstream market.

EN: Of your other books do you have a personal favorite?

MF: Until publishing the new book, Zenith City: Stories from Duluth, my favorite of my books was One Shining Season, the story about 11 major league baseball's one-year wonders. Great fun to do; the ballplayers were storytellers and I got to put those stories on the page. My wife's favorite is my short novel, Indians in the Arborvitae, though for her, too, it's now replaced by Zenith City.

EN: Any advice you would give to young people who wish to become writers?

MF: First of all, most of us in this trade can't not write; it's like breathing. I don't know any writers who are not compulsive and disciplined. The old cliche says that everyone has a book deep within. This is probably true, and some people do record and publish memoirs or their account of a famous war battle, but they aren't in for the long haul. The most important thing for aspiring writers is to be a reader, and more than that, read everything, including what you think is beneath you. Read it all. You'll develop not only taste, but discernment so you can self-edit. Next to reading, write. Write daily if possible. Set word or page limits and try to adhere to that. I have taught writing at the Loft and at workshops and have encountered students whose talents exceeded my own. Few of them ever published though, because they either didn't need to, or felt the process required too much effort. I publish because I'm serious about the work and stay with it.

 # # # #


Final resting place for Elias Clayton, Elmer Jackson and Isaac McGhie



Wednesday, June 11, 2014

A Few Thoughts About the Clayton Jackson McGhie Memorial

This past week I got into a discussion with a friend regarding Michael Fedo's book The Lynching In Duluth which led into talking about the Clayton Jackson McGhie Memorial. To my surprise he had fairly strong feelings against the memorial. When I asked why he said that things like this only foster hatred.

This reaction completely surprised me, but it showed clearly how the ideas, observations and conclusions we've come to in our own minds can often be completely at odds with where others are at. Once we recognize this, and hopefully when we are young, then we begin to recognize the value of dialogue, of listening and hearing.

Dialogue is one of those things that takes courage because there are so many barriers to communication, one of them being our own fear of rejection for ideas or feelings we might have. But dialogue is important, and essential to reconciliation. This is, I believe, one of the aims of the Clayton Jackson McGhie Memorial, to foster dialogue that can lead to reconciliation and healing for our city.

Police station, after it was over.
This year marks the 94th anniversary of the tragedy that ended the lives of Elias Clayton, Elmer Jackson and Isaac McGhie, three young African American men who were falsely accused, taken by a mob from the old Duluth jail on East Superior Street, and lynched at the intersection where the CJM Memorial now stands. The story of how this memorial came into being eleven years ago can be found here: www.claytonjacksonmcghie.org/CreationMemorial

The importance of remembering this event isn't just in regards to race relations, though there are many lessons there. I find it important because of what it teaches us about mobs, about mob violence and the importance of civil and civilized relations. I saw the power of a mob when I was in college, how emotions were stirred, how people were manipulated, and the subsequent damage. The breakdown of order into disorder takes people down strange paths. But let's not forget the racial component either.

All this to say that there are some events the CJMM Committee has announced for this week ahead.

• Sunday, June 15, 6PM, Park Hill Cemetery, 2500 Vermillion Rd — Join us a vigil at the gravesites of Elias Clayton, Elmer Jackson and Isaac McGhie for a gathering that includes storytelling, ribbon tying, and laying of flowers.

• Monday, June 16, 12:00 PM, Clayton Jackson McGhie Memorial, First St & Second Ave E — Day of Remembrance: Building Trust within Communities
Community members will gather to honor the memory of the three young men who were lynched in 1920. Special guest speakers include: Mayor Don Ness, Natasha Lancour, and Stephan Witherspoon. Come and meet and hear from our 2014 Scholarship Recipient Taneasha Muonio, recent graduate of Duluth Denfeld High School heading to Augsberg College this fall.

• Monday, June 16, 1-3 PM, Building for Women, 32 E First St, Basement — Reception
Come see our board meeting space and enjoy some conversation and refreshments with us. We will be accepting donations at this time for our scholarship fund.

• Monday, June 15, 6-8:30 PM, Fitger’s Spirit of the North Theater and The Bookstore at Fitger’s, 600 E Superior St, 3rd Floor — Educational Event and Book Signing The Ku Klux Klan in Minnesota by Elizabeth Dorsey Hatle. Join us at 6:30pm for a Meet and Greet with the author, at 7pm there will be a book reading and Powerpoint Presentation tailored to Duluth, followed by a book signing by the author at the Bookstore at 7:30pm.

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

The Lynchings In Duluth by Michael Fedo

"They're selling postcards of the hanging..." ~ Bob Dylan, Desolation Row

From the postcard of the hanging.
For a compelling read I strongly recommend The Lynchings in Duluth by Michael Fedo. The book is an eye-opening account of one of the darkest moments in Duluth history, well-researched and well-written. Even though its subject matter is close to home -- it happened right downtown -- the insights one can garner from its pages are universal in terms of giving a broader understanding of race relations in America.

The events were real. In mid-June 1920 a travelling circus was in town. A young white couple had gone out to the part of town where the circus was and an incident occurred. When the woman said she was raped, rumors spread and events were set in motion that resulted in outrageous events, culminating initially in the lynching of three black circus workers and later the sentencing of a fourth to thirty years in prison. The harrowing night of that lynching and its aftermath is what this book about.

When I think about the lynchings that took place here I am reminded of Walter Van Tilburg Clark's The Ox-Bow Incident, which Hollywood later made into a film starring Henry Fonda and Anthony Quinn. It's a story about a mob that is spurred to action after drawing conclusions based on erroneous information. Noble intentions (a desire for justice) often have ignoble ends.

What makes Fedo's book so compelling is the manner in which the story is told, recounting hour-by-hour the spreading of the rumor, the response by various parts of the city, the responses by police and those in authority, the growing clamor in the streets and the ultimate battle between the mob and the deputies. It must have been a night of terror for the incarcerated black workers as well as for the policemen striving to defend them, putting their lives on the line.

The story doesn't end with the events of that night of violence. There were men brought to trial. First, the white folk who incited the riots were tried. Nineteen men had been arrested on charges of inciting to riot to first degree murder. All were released on bail. The blacks who had been arrested earlier had not even been arraigned. Two of these men would remain in jail for more than five months before going to trial on rape charges.

The trial of the whites did result in a few convictions but, as Fedo notes, "Duluthians found themselves uneasy about convicting men who carried out their own sympathies, and felt the issue would best be forgotten." In other words, in the minds of the public the girl was raped and the victims of the lynchings probably got what they deserved.

The Claywon-Jacvkson-McGhie Memorial in Duluth.
What makes the book masterful is the manner in which the author lays out the facts, the details as they were known, the improbability of what was being claimed and impossibility of the rest of it. Fedo does this carefully because the descendants still live among us. Out of respect for privacy he changed the names of the young woman and her boyfriend in this re-telling, but the evidence is fairly clear that their story was fabricated.

One piece of evidence used to prove that the girl was raped was that she had contracted gonorrhea from one of the circus workers who raped her. Nineteen black men were tested and only one test came back positive, that of Max Mason who said he did indeed have gonorrhea a year previous but was clean now. An inept defense in court resulted in Mason being charged and convicted for rape, and sentenced to 30 years. Fedo shows readers how impossible this was as well, that the girl had an advanced gonorrhea, and that Mason never received any treatment while in jail.... because he didn't need it.

All too often we think of lynchings as something remote and distant. We say to ourselves, "It can't happen here," but it did happen here. Billie Holiday's Strange Fruit gave us a glimpse of the hauntedness that festers beneath the surface when these kinds of things happen. Fedo showed us the unhealthy impact our lynching here had on the black community in Duluth, and the broader community's soul.

The Lynchings in Duluth is available at Barnes & Noble locally, and can also be found at Amazon.

Popular Posts