Showing posts with label collapse. Show all posts
Showing posts with label collapse. Show all posts

Sunday, March 17, 2024

How Immigration Contributed to the Fall of the Roman Empire

They say that those who fail to learn from history are destined to repeat it. When I learned several years back about the factors that contributed to the decline and fall of Rome, I was not surprised at the role immigration played. What did-and still does--surprise me is how the immigration issue is never brought up as something that has historical precedents. 

Immigration was not the sole factor in the fall of Rome, but it was definitely one of the factors that contributed to the fall of this once-great empire. And when one looks back at this period of history, it all makes sense. (Common sense is no longer common, unfortunately.)

During the later years of the Roman Empire, particularly in the 4th and 5th centuries AD, the empire faced significant challenges from both external invasions and internal unrest. Here are a couple of the ways immigration played a role in these challenges. Look at the parallels to what's been happening in Europe and the U.S. today. 


Economic Strain 
The influx of immigrants placed strain on the Roman economy, particularly as the empire struggled to provide resources and employment for its growing population. Immigrants often settled in urban areas, leading to overcrowding, unemployment, and social unrest. This economic strain further weakened the empire's ability to defend itself against external threats. (Sound familiar?)


Cultural and Social Change
Immigration also brought about cultural and social changes within the Roman Empire. As immigrants settled in Roman territory, they brought with them their own languages, customs, and beliefs, leading to increased cultural diversity and, in some cases, tensions between different ethnic and religious groups. These divisions weakened the sense of unity and cohesion that had been essential to the stability of the empire.


We constantly hear people extol the virtues of diversity, but how is that working out in real life over in the EU which has embraced diversity to almost a radical degree? According to Douglas Murray: 


But the argument for mass migration on the grounds of 'diversity' as being a good in itself ignores one huge and until recently unspeakable issue. Just as most cultures have good things to say for themselves, all have some bad and disagreeable things about them too. And while the positives can be stressed and exaggerated from the outset, any negatives take years to admit, if they are admitted at all.


It strikes me as strange that our culture has become so polarized that we cannot discuss anything with resorting to name-calling. If one argues against mass immigration, they are labelled a xenophobe.


In the last decades of the Roman Empire, there were all kinds of groups fleeing into Roman territory seeking a better opportunity. Visigoths, Vandals and Huns came because they were fleeing the conflicts in their own lands. According to historians the pressure from these migrations contributed to the weakening and eventual collapse of central authority.  


* * * * 

Immigration wasn't the only thing that undermined the Roman Empire. There were other causes as well, including some quite familiar to us today like overexpansion, military overspending and government corruption. Nevertheless, immigration played a part.


I'm just sowing seeds here. There are reasons to be concerned about the direction things are going. Those speaking frankly may have useful contributions on this matter and ought not be dismissed out of hand. My gut tells me things will be getting worse before they get better unless honest discussions are allowed to take place in our communities, cities and highest levels of government. I'm less than optimistic.


Tuesday, September 6, 2022

Is the Old World Order on the Verge of Collapse?

How precarious is our future? Is the world really on the verge of economic collapse? What would a global economic collapse look like?

Here's a podcast that makes a case for the Doom scenario. At this moment in time most of us are living on faith, faith that the power grid will sustain us, that the banking systems will remain operational, that goods and services will continue as they have in the past. 

Peter Zeihan is a geopolitical analyst who spells out why the next 50 years will look very different than the last fifty years. 

Here's what makes the economy work: a mix or consumers, investors and workers. Because of the demographics shift taking place, all three are on the decline.  

This video is an hour long. If you listen to the first ten minutes you'll get some striking insights from a perspective you probably haven't thought that much about. 

The Old World Order Is About To Collapse - Peter Zeihan

Modern Wisdom Podcast 514

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRT7P-VKM0k


* * * 

This is just a discussion starter.

Whatcha think?

Thursday, October 27, 2016

Throwback Thursday: How Will It End?

The Truman Show, starring Jim Carrey as Truman, is a wonderfully original film about a man whose whole life, unbeknownst to him, has been lived in front of TV cameras. His life is a TV show. The story becomes a vehicle for many insights and questions about our own lives, the roles we play, our level of awareness as regards what is really going on outside our own little world.

One of the themes in the film is a pin Truman is wearing. "When Will It End?"

Despite the comic story line, amplified by Carrey's naturally inventive style, the film is serious in tone. And this question is not simply for Truman's audience, but for each of us as well.

We're all familiar with sayings like "it came to pass," with which we comfort ourselves during hard times or a cold spell. Nothing lasts forever, we say. Yet when we say this, we seldom apply this across the board. We generally live as if we ourselves are not going anywhere any time soon. And by extension, few of us can imagine a future in which the United States is no longer the United States.

So when we read books and articles about the fall of the Roman Empire, designed to teach us lessons about how nations and empires fall, how is it that we do not, almost cannot, relate it to our own nation, which is currently the world's strongest superpower?

Last Saturday I wrote about bread and circuses. Someone responded Monday by sharing an article with me from the Wall Street Journal that day regarding a prediction that the U.S. will be history by 2010. According to Andrew Osborn, a certain Igor Panarin has predicted for more than a decade that the U.S. will break up in a civil war due to economic and moral collapse.

This is no lightweight academic. Panarin is a former KGB analyst who is head of the Russian Foreign Ministry's academy for future diplomats. The factors that will bring us down include "mass immigration, economic decline, and moral degradation"... along with collapse of the dollar. His new portrait of our United States will be a breakup into six pieces, Alaska ultimately returning to Russian control.

The story sounds far fetched, but stranger things have happened. No one expected the USSR to unravel as quickly as it did when the Soviet empire began to implode. Would the Wall Street Journal print something like this if it were the rantings of a lunatic? The friend who forwarded this article found it on The Drudge Report.
There was a time when Britain basked in the glow of knowing that the sun never set on the British Empire. How long can the United States be so blissfully oblivious to the reality that all things must pass?

Which leads directly to my question. How will it end? Nothing lasts forever. We know that. So, what next? The evidence that America is in decline is all around. Predictions of decline have been heralded for some time. How serious is our sickness? Will the patient recover?

Is this all too far out? You tell me... because an inquiring mind wants to know.

Popular Posts