Wednesday, October 15, 2025

It Takes a Lot of Courage to Be a Contrarian

In a world that rewards conformity, being a contrarian isn't just bold—it's downright heroic. Picture this: You're in a boardroom. An idea is proposed that is clearly off the wall, but to your surprise one by one everyone around the table affirms that this is a good idea, nodding along in agreement. When it's your turn, do you zip it or say, "Wait, this is silly." Or, more tactfully, you suggest that they are pros and cons to everything and you suggest there may be another way to look at this.

Hearts race, eyes narrow. Why? Because challenging the status quo demands courage—the kind that separates visionaries from the herd. 

History is littered with contrarians who reshaped our world. Galileo stared down the Inquisition, insisting the Earth orbited the Sun, not vice versa. He faced house arrest, yet his defiance made a significant contribution to modern astronomy. 


Fast-forward to 2008. Michael Burry, the investor immortalized in The Big Short, bet against the housing market when Wall Street laughed him off. Labeled a lunatic, he profited billions while the economy crumbled. Or consider Rosa Parks, whose simple refusal to move sparked the Civil Rights Movement. These weren't reckless rebels, brave souls who put something on the line to go against tradition.


So, why does contrarianism require such guts? First, the social sting. Humans are wired for belonging. Dissent risks isolation, mockery, or (in our social media age) worse—cancellation. Second, there's a personal toll. Doubt creeps in when you're the lone voice. Self-doubt whispers, "What if I'm wrong?" Or perhaps the more common response, "Is this my line in the sand? Is this an issue I want to be a martyr for?"


It's challenging to stand alone, and sometimes costly. See (or read) Ibsen's An Enemy of the People.


When others are hugging the status quo, being contrarian can be the driving force of innovation. Steve Jobs bucked the trend of button-heavy phones with the iPhone, turning Apple into a trillion-dollar titan. Warren Buffett thrived by zigging when others zag, famously advising to "be fearful when others are greedy."


Being contrarian isn't about being difficult—it's about integrity. It takes courage to question echo chambers, whether in politics, business, or daily life. (Where are the individualist voices in the GOP or Dem parties? What is all this unapologetic party lockstep alignment about?) 


As for courage, yes, it's necessary. Why do we hold back? Someone once said courage is like a muscle that is strengthened with use. And like a virus, it's contagious.


Embrace the discomfort. The world needs more contrarians—not to divide, but to elevate us.  


Illustration: A Gemini 2.5 modified version of one of my doodle drawings.

2 comments:

Richard Scott said...

There are individual voices in the Democratic party who are willing to break with party leadership, notably Zorhan Momdani and AOC--the latter of whom, I love reminding you, you called "crazy," and she turned out to be correct. On the other side was Joe Manchin, who was to the right of the public on abortion, gun rights, and voting rights, proving that individualism doesn't always make one brave, but can show a staggering lack of political spine.

Ed Newman said...

To your list I would add Bernie, who was shafted by the DNC, and Ron Paul who consistently called for fiscal responsbility and non-interventionist foreign policy and an end to "American Empire"... which has been growing since the Spanish-American War.

Popular Posts